Infertility: A Word For Pastors, Counselors, & Those Who Struggle

by Donna Gibbs

The wedding was beautiful. Lifelong hopes and dreams became a reality as the vows were spoken and the couple was introduced to those in attendance. The bride and groom started down the aisle, full of aspirations for a hope-filled, joyous life together. They pictured themselves living the American dream, with a beautiful home, a Volvo in the garage, and 2.4 children.

Time passed. One year turned into two, then three, four, and five years. Family and friends began to question, “When are you two going to have a baby?” “You know, you’re not getting any younger.” “Isn’t it about time you started having a family?” 

For this couple, infertility was soon becoming a harsh reality. They considered the time, energy, finances, and emotional strain involved in medical interventions or adoption. It was all so confusing and overwhelming. They prayed, questioning God, asking “Why?” Why were relationships becoming strained? Why was walking down the baby food aisle of the grocery store becoming unbearable? Why were announcements of pregnancies and baby showers so painful? Why was Mother’s Day such a sad occasion? Why?

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, almost 11% of reproductive-aged women experience challenges in getting pregnant and/or carrying a baby to term. This is probably a low estimate of the many isolated, hurting couples with few places to turn with their grief. Infertility is a disease that creates significant grief, bombarding its victims with intense, inexplicable emotions. The grief process can be experienced from one extreme to another, all within a cycle of 28 days. Infertility attacks an individual’s sense of self-worth, tempting them to compare themselves to peers who seem to have no difficulty achieving or maintaining pregnancy.  Certainly, infertility can place great strain on relationships among family and friends who often, with no evil intent, have painful questions and expectations. An unresolved plea for pregnancy can also create stress and tension in the marriage relationship. Without question, undesired childlessness shakes our faith in a God who describes children as a blessed gift.

Yet, there is hope! For we serve a God who makes promises. The promise for someone with infertility is not that they would necessarily have a biological child (though approximately 85-90% are able to conceive). The promise is that even this difficult trial will be worked for good. “And we know that all things work together for good to those who love God, to those who are called according to His purpose” (Romans 8:28). “All things” is an all-inclusive phrase: even infertility can bear fruit! 

In all likelihood, if you are a counselor or a minister, you have encountered couples who are experiencing the trial of infertility. Below, I’ve listed a few tips for working with these couples and hope that these assist you in providing a supportive and effective atmosphere for them. 

ROLE OF THE PASTOR/COUNSELOR/MENTOR

*To be well versed regarding the emotional, relational, and spiritual challenges of infertility,  as well as reproductive treatment options. Just as we would want to be aware of cultural differences that can impact our clients, we need to be aware of the life and challenges of the couple experiencing infertility. 

*Normalize and validate the common struggles at each phase of infertility grief (see “Processing Infertility Grief”. 

*Educate regarding gender differences in infertility grief and assist the couple in processing their grief without divisiveness. 

*Refer couples to support groups if available, at minimum mentors who can relate in a non-threatening and supportive manner. This is particularly important due to the isolation that generally accompanies infertility. If no resources are locally available, advocate for the development of these resources. 

*Educate couples regarding stress management techniques. Infertility is known to be as stressful for individuals as a life-threatening condition. 

*Assist couples in making deliberate, well-processed decisions regarding their treatment options, taking into consideration spiritual convictions, financial obstacles, family dynamics, stress-levels, etc… 

*Assist clients, through role-play, in communicating their struggles, needs, and hurts to family, friends, and co-workers as it relates to infertility. Assist couples in determining what they are comfortable sharing with others and in explaining what they prefer to be kept private, how they will respond to announcements of pregnancy, invitations to baby showers, etc… This type of rehearsal assists couples in overcoming isolation and resentment. 

*Have couples journal their experiences and emotions and process in session. 

Processing Infertility Grief, taken from Water From the Rock, co-authored by Donna Gibbs (these are expected experiences of grief related to infertility) 

*Denial/Shock: “I can’t believe this is happening to me.” 

*Desperation/Panic: “I’ll do whatever it takes to have a child.” 

*Anger/Resentment: “What kind of God would allow me to go through this?” 

*Sadness/Depression: “Why me?” 

*Inadequacy/Guilt: “What is my purpose now?” 

*Hope/Peace: “I’m OK.” 

*Reconciliation/Integration: “May Your will be done.”

by Donna Gibbs

Touch to Call